Looking for the full walkthrough and complete chapter listing for Scarlet Hollow?
View the Complete Walkthrough HubThe Manor
Chapter 3 starts at the Manor. As you wake up in the guest bedroom, you can choose to take a shower. Next you can check the drawers to find there are now two opossums. You need TALK TO ANIMALS to get through to them. You can choose to text Stella or Kaneeka to progress with your specific romance.
I chose to text Stella. You can choose to send Kaneeka a text and one to the group chat as well. Other than that nothing else to do now. Head downstairs.
The Kitchen
You will meet Janey now. Once the pleasantries are over you can interrogate Tabitha over the events of the last day.
Tabitha will now drag you to the general store for some errands. Janey will approach you and mention that her husband, Daniel is the local pastor.
General Store
Tabitha is here to buy Sybil’s tea. Kaneeka will storm out of the store as you head in. Tabitha and Sybil will head to the back. KEEN EYE and STREET SMART allow you to listen in on the conversation between Tabitha and Sybil. If you had saved Duke in Chapter 1, he will now show up with Bo. If you didn’t save him, only Bo will show up.
Duke will tell you about his chicken and comment on Rosalina. You can also find out about Julius from them. Once they leave the story gives you options (depending on your previous choices.)
Go After Kaneeka – This is an essential choice to romance Kaneeka.
Swing by Stella’s – This choice is essential to romance Stella.
Go to the diner to see Avery – This is for romancing Avery and learning about things overheard in the diner.
Wait for Tabitha – If you want to bond with Tabitha, this part is important.
I chose to go for breakfast at Stella’s.
Stella’s House
You will have the option to flirt with Stella here.
Update her on everything that’s going on and you know. Finish with the ghost hunt later tonight. Eventually, after a lot of conversation and breakfast you will head to the library.
Library
You will now meet Mayor Jimmy. If you don’t have TALK TO ANIMALS, you will wish you had it now. If you don’t, follow Kaneeka and Stella out to meet Oscar. But you will be interrupted by Pastor Daniel.
Daniel will eventually hand you his card. Meet up with the gang and talk to Oscar. Eventually the option to invite Avery and Tabitha will come up. If you have both options, you should do so.
Finally head to Reese’s.
Reese’s House
You will meet Doctor Kelly for the first time here, if you didn’t run into her earlier.
Follow the gang to the basement to Reese’s room. Reese has a mysterious illness and draws creepy stuff. During your time in the basement is the first opportunity you will get to flirt with REESE and if you want to pursue him you need to take it. Once you go back up for dinner you will be drawn to a door in the clinic.
The doctor will show up and move you to the table. During the dinner, you can accuse Dr Kelly of poisoning her son along with a bunch of other stuff. There is a metric where the tension keeps rising at the table. I chose to not push it as I might need her later. Eventually you will leave. Once outside you will theorize that a similar carving to the one in the mines is in the clinic.
Eventually you will head to the library.
The Library
Who shows up to the ghost hunt depends on who you saved in the mine and who you invited along. The usual group is Stella, Kaneeka, Oscar, Zane, and Rosalina. Optional attendees include Avery, Tabitha, Alexis, and Gretchen. Bringing Tabitha in particular is worth it. It helps with bonding so that she doesn’t get you arrested later in Episode 5. This also helps with the achievement.
Once the gang is together, they will head to Rosalina’s room. For the “best” outcome to this event, BOOKSMART is quite important.
Stella will remove the carpet and find a trap door. After a lot of back and forth, Stella will try to open the hatch and you and Tabitha will be together. Eventually you will end up in a weird area.
Stella or someone who looks like Stella will pop up. Play through the conversation. I chose to go after Stella. Another scene. Try to pick options with BOOKSMART if they are available.
Eventually you will step out to a garden at night. This time Kaneeka will show up in the scene.
Once you are done with Kaneeka, Sam Wayne will show up.
Tabitha will run off with you. And eventually you will see Zane and Oscar.
Oscar will fall through the bed. Tabitha will follow, follow after her. The next room will have Avery in it. Pick the BOOKSMART options and eventually you will come up to a door with countless locks.
Follow the path to Stella again. Eventually the ghost will show up. Pretty soon you and Tabitha will be on trial for the crimes of your family. Due to having picked my background as a lawyer and having booksmart, I defended me and Tabitha and escaped judgement. You will be in a basement and Sybil is there. If you dig the shallow ground you will find another carving.
Speak to everyone outside. Sybil will invite you for tea in Chapter 4.
Eventually with all the dialogue options exhausted head back to the Mansion.
The Manor
Speak to Tabitha about everything that happened then turn in.
This concludes the walkthrough for Chapter 3 of Scarlet Hollow.
More indie games
For more articles on other indie games, please check out the links below:
Videogames.
Gym.
Sneakers.
Manga.
My dog.
In that order.
